Lots of honey bees working the Banksia Rose blossoms this morning: I wonder where their hive is? Made another batch of Dijon style mustard — doubled the ingredients and bottled one kg. No point waiting four weeks to test; I need to stock up.
Olive Oil
We use olive oil in our food preparation and last week this article caught my attention; I returned to it today and read it more carefully. “Oils ain’t oils, extra virgin tests show”, SMH, 3 October, http://www.smh.com.au/national/oils-aint-oils-extra-virgin-tests-show-20091002-ggj4.html.
Some excerpts:
The results of comprehensive tests conducted earlier this year by Modern Olives Laboratory in Melbourne showed a failure rate of 80 per cent for imported extra virgin olive oil, the World Congress of Oils and Fats was told in Sydney this week.
The results showed that more than 40 imported olive oils had either been adulterated with cheaper oils such as canola, had gone through a refining process or had spoiled due to age or poor storage techniques.
But while most of the major local extra virgin oil producers were already adhering to the association’s certification standards and its code of conduct, Aldi had been the only big supermarket chain so far to demand certification of all its extra virgin olive oil.
For some time we bought one-litre bottles of Woolworth’s Home Brand extra virgin until I discovered Syrian oil at the local greengrocer – four litres for $26 and it looked extra-virgin and smelt and tasted good. Then one day at Aldi we bought 20 litres of Oroysol for $20, a blend of refined and extra virgin oil, which we have continued to use. Next trip to Aldi we will check the price on their extra virgin.
We have a thriving olive tree at Hyams Beach and our neighbour harvested the crop last summer for pickling — when he gets back from Italy we must get a jar.
Yesterday’s Media Tosh
Genetically engineered food reared up yesterday in “Panel voices fears as unlabelled GE canola hits shelves”, SMH, 14 October, http://www.smh.com.au/environment/panel-voices-fears-as-unlabelled-ge-canola-hits-shelves-20091013-gvqg.html. GE food is, apparently, banned in the European Union and Japan. It appears that one significant part of the GE problem is based on hostility of Monsanto who have been heavy-handed in protecting their patents. Another is the effect of GE plants on the world’s seed pool — GE could lead to a shrinking of plant diversity. This viewpoint comes from Deconstructing Dinner podcasts; they are opposed to GE cropping due to the pollution of non-GE canola, hence its impact on seed diversity, and the behaviour of Monsanto. I have followed the struggle of Percy Schmeiser who was persecuted by Monsanto when his canola was contaminated by GE canola (http://www.percyschmeiser.com/). But hostility does not equate to knowledge and I am left puzzling why so little research. As a consumer. I am interested in the health aspects of GE canola and it is from this view I comment on the SMH article and Greenpeace’s stance.
Here are selected quotes from the SMH article and my comments.
From oils to margarine, baby food to snacks, muesli to dairy products, GE canola oil can be found in many processed foods, but consumers are oblivious to what food it is in.
This is not unusual in Australia where food-labeling practice is slipshod
Ms Porteous said the risk of locally grown GE canola becoming part of Australia’s oil supplies was a critical issue.
The major ‘risk’ is loss of export markets.
She said there were concerns about health problems, sustainability and biodiversity, apart from agricultural contamination. ‘’There hasn’t been any long-term tests on the impact on human health,’’ she said.
Ms Porteous is correct; there have been no long-term studies on the health impact of GE canola. Why?
‘’There have been a number of studies that have shown GE food to have serious health impacts on the immune system.
I can find only one conducted trial; on rats by Monsanto, which caused liver damage to 15 per cent of the test animals. This is significant so wonder why Greenpeace and others have not encouraged or funded follow-up research.
The author of Good Health in the 21st Century, Dr Carole Hungerford, said there could be health implications for gut bacteria if GE food was consumed regularly.
“…there could be health implications for gut bacteria…”, but she doesn’t know. Guessing is not knowledge. On checking Dr Hungerford’s web site (http://www.carolehungerford.com.au/index.htm) there are no references to any research she has conducted to support her comments.
”The genes from GM foods can get into the gut bacteria and the gut bacteria is the most critical thing.
Speculation is not knowledge.
A search for “GE canola” on http://www.greenpeace.org/australia/ returned 100 plus responses. Looking at the first ten, I could find no reference to health implications other than ‘speculation’.
- Australia, learn from Canadian mistakes with GE Canola … Planting GE canola cost Canada valuable export markets, writes Canadian professor, Dr Rene Van Acker. www.greenpeace.org/australia/news-and…/australia-learn-from-canadian.
Nothing about the health hazards from GE canola.
- Greenpeace Australia Pacific » Blog Archive » Would you sow GE …30 Jan 2009 … Remember when trials of genetically engineered (GE) canola were … GE canola yielded 17% less than non-GE herbicide-tolerant canola ….www.greenpeace.org.au/blog/energy/?p=396
Nothing about the health hazards from GE canola.
- Greenpeace finds honey contaminated with genetically engineered …1 Oct 2009 … Geelong, Australia — Greenpeace has found commercial beehives contaminated with genetically engineered (GE) canola pollen near Geelong. … www.greenpeace.org/australia/news…/greenpeace-finds-honey-contami
“This means that people buying honey from this hive will be eating GE food without knowing it, and before it has been properly assessed that it’s safe to eat,” said Greenpeace GE campaigner Louise Sales.
Melbourne restaurateur Duré Dara has come to the site to express her concerns: “We need our governments to be more responsible to think about genetically engineered food in a much more considered way. Food protection is an issue that affects tourism, our world image and the health of our citizens.” Ms Dara co-manages the Nudel Bar and Residential restaurants and is one of nearly 200 leading chefs and restaurateurs who have signed the GM-free Chef’s Charter.
But no one yet knows the health hazards from GE canola.
- Greenpeace Australia Pacific » Blog Archive » WA Divided on GE …24 Apr 2009 … The WA Senate this month passed a motion to disallow field trials (the stage before commercial growing) of GE canola. … www.greenpeace.org.au/blog/energy/?p=475
Nothing about the health hazards from GE canola. And do they mean the Legislative Council? There are no State Senates.
- GE Canola – out of control in Canada | Greenpeace Australia Pacific 17 Dec 2007 … Why contamination by genetically modified canola is inevitable in Australia if the current GM crop bans are lifted. www.greenpeace.org/australia/resources/…/GE/ge-canola-out-of-control-in
Nothing about the health hazards from GE canola.
- Canola | Greenpeace Australia Pacific Australia is the world’s second largest producer of the oilseed crop known as canola (Brassica napus), after Canada. www.greenpeace.org/australia/issues/GE/overview/problem/…/ge…/canola
Nothing about the health hazards from GE canola.
- Why this Canadian farmer stopped growing GE canola | Greenpeace …Canadian farmer Ross Murray used to grow genetically engineered (GE) canola. That is until he discovered the GE canola wasn’t delivering on its promise and …www.greenpeace.org/australia/resources/videos/GE/farmerstour1-110309
Nothing about the health hazards from GE canola.
- Genetically Engineered Canola: The Reality Behind the Myths …In 2008, Australia’s first commercial genetically engineered (GE) canola crops were grown in NSW and Victoria. In this briefing we take six of the GE …www.greenpeace.org/australia/resources/fact-sheets/…/gecanolamyths-jan08GE canola poses a serious threat to the environment, animal and human health and will cost farmers their GE-free reputation and their markets.Reality: There have been no long-term studies looking at the impacts of GE food on human health. Studies that have been done raise serious concerns.
Why no further studies?
- Japan rejects GE canola | Greenpeace Australia Pacific 12 Feb 2008 … Japanese activists have projected a warning to Australia on a grain silo and a ship carrying genetically engineered (GE) canola: “Australia … www.greenpeace.org/australia/news-and…/japanese-activists-tell-austra
Nothing about the health hazards from GE canola.
- Japanese set to reject genetically engineered canola | Greenpeace …1 Sep 2009 … The change of government in Japan is likely to have a significant impact on Australia’s canola exports, since the Democratic Party of Japan … www.greenpeace.org/australia/news-and…/japanese-set-to-reject-genetic
Nothing about the health hazards from GM canola but speculation that Australia’s exports will be effected.
We rarely use canola oil so I am assuming that unlike the Monsanto rats, our livers will not be affected. This hectoring by well-intentioned NGOs diminishes their power. I was once an admirer of Greenpeace but this ill-informed lobbying practice does nothing to restore my respect. It would also be useful if Kelly Burke, the author of the SMH article, did some basic research instead of reproducing a PR handout.
This photo is of canola in WA (http://contribute.abc.net.au/_Canola-Crops/photo/5242078/32422.html) .

Photo 1: Paddocks of Canola can be seen in WA's South at present. Spectacularly beautiful – Maggie May
Technical Note
Google Webmaster Tools are now installed on hyamsbeach.org, which will launch the search engine spider to index the site. Theoretically, when someone searches for onion recipes, preserving, Ansel Adams and other matters that I have written on, the blog should be somewhere in the results. So far all I can see is that there is an error in ‘parsing’. Have no idea what this means.
I have moved the Hyams Beach web site to the root directory of http://hyamsbeach.org/ and the result is sloppy. Pages and photos don’t open but correcting these problems is within my ability whereas dealing with Coogle and WordPress leaves me mystified.
FatCow have been active on the slow response time; “The issue you have reported should now be resolved, please check from your end and let us know if you need additional assistance”. Time will tell. Earlier today any editing became unstable and I lost much formatting.
Today’s Podcast
“Afghanistan: the unwinnable war”, Rear Vision, 14 October, http://www.abc.net.au/rn/rearvision/stories/2009/2707617.htm
As the Obama administration carries out a major review of strategy in the increasingly unpopular war, Rear Vision traces eight years of conflict in Afghanistan.
Today’s Blog
Dudu Diaries: Notes from the world of an insect lover, http://dududiaries.wildlifedirect.org/
INSECT BLOGGING IN KENYA
Dino Martins is an entomologist in Kenya who as well as making a study of insects in Kenya, keeps an up-to-date blog of his activities. Dino Martins takes the listener on a field trip through insect habitat in Kenya. Digital Planet, http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p004hhnr
Some excellent photos and well worth listening to him on the Digital Planet podcast.